Design-vs-implementation review found the comparison path missing two
reinforcements the single-topic path has: the windowed-claims rule (no
trend verbs from one 30-day window) and an explicit artifact gate. It
also pointed the beat at a "narrative section" the comparison template
doesn't have. The per-entity template block now carries an explicit
optional pitch-vs-pulse slot (omit entirely when silent - no
placeholder), and the comparison instruction names that slot, the
windowed rule, and the no-fetch-no-pitch gate. Instructions now sit at
the emission point, per the file's own v3.0.6/v3.0.7 lesson about
distance between instruction and output.
Review showed the "Setting the narrative?" verdict compared across
abstraction levels: a homepage tagline is deliberately broad
("financial infrastructure" covers a chargebacks thread), so
tagline-vs-thread alignment verdicts are unfalsifiable and carry no
information. The signal now ships as PROSE in the entity's narrative
section, fires only when the month's evidence directly bears on the
pitch (supports a specific claim, cuts against one, or is squarely
about the pitched ground), and stays SILENT when the pulse is
orthogonal - omission over a manufactured connection. Claims are
tested at matched altitude (specific claim vs specific thread) and
stay windowed (no trend verbs one 30-day window can't support). The
positioning fetch step survives unchanged and now also grounds the
"What it is" row and brand-noise rejection. All scope gating (people
never, ownerless topics excluded, no pitch from memory) carries over.
The lens criterion is now explicit: an identifiable first party with a
fetchable public pitch - companies, products, services. People NEVER
qualify, even founders whose companies would (MrBeast the company can
get the lens; Jimmy Donaldson the person cannot; "Garry Tan vs Sam
Altman" gets N/A across the row). Ownerless topics (Bitcoin) fail the
same test - a foundation or fan site is not an authoritative first
party. Comparison-row verdicts are also artifact-gated to match the
single-entity beat: a verdict requires positioning fetched THIS run;
if item 6 couldn't run (no WebSearch), the cell is Unclear - the pitch
is never supplied from memory.
CHANGELOG covers the narrative lens (Added) and head-token grounding
fix (Fixed). CONCEPTS.md gains a Research pipeline cluster (Primary
entity, Intent modifier, Entity grounding, Keyless path,
Comment-enrichment slots). New docs/solutions/logic-errors/ entry
captures the false-demotion bug, the rejected alternatives, and the
shared-helper prevention rule.
The entity-grounding demotion required the full multi-word primary
entity as a contiguous substring, so on-entity items missing a trailing
search descriptor were buried: a 323-pt HN thread "Stripe is friendly
to 'friendly fraud'" scored 0 on a "Stripe payments" query. New
_entity_grounded helper keys on the brand head token; items that never
name the brand still miss it and stay demoted. reddit_keyless
_slot_priority, which had re-implemented the old check while claiming
to mirror rerank's signal, now calls the shared helper so the two
paths cannot diverge.
Comparison tables gain a narrative axis judging whether each entity's
community conversation is about what the entity pitches or about
something else (pricing, rivals, an incident). Backed by a new
mandatory Step 0.55 research item that fetches each entity's CURRENT
first-party positioning (RESOLVED_POSITIONING) instead of relying on
memory, and a narrative-check synthesis beat for single-entity company
runs. The mismatch is the signal: companies usually don't control
their own conversation.
The ScrapeCreators 402 (payment required / credits exhausted) status
was being swallowed by the broad except Exception handlers in
_global_search, _subreddit_search, and fetch_post_comments, returning
[] instead of propagating. That caused users with exhausted credits
to silently get zero Reddit results instead of falling through to
the OpenAI / public Reddit JSON fallback chain in _search_reddit_thread.
Add 402 to the existing 401/403 re-raise list across all three
ScrapeCreators call paths. Closes#170.
Co-authored-by: Jonathan Oppenheim <no-reply@postquantum.space>
Reddit's public JSON endpoint returns 403 to requests carrying the
generic User-Agent and minimal header set urllib defaults to, while
matching curl requests succeed. Switch to a current-Chrome User-Agent
and add Accept-Language / Accept-Encoding / Connection headers so the
fingerprint matches a normal browser. Reddit now serves gzip when
Accept-Encoding includes it, so decompress the body before JSON parse.
Update the user-agent assertion in tests/test_reddit_public.py to match
the new browser-like string. Closes#199.
Co-authored-by: Franco Carballar <francocarballar@gmail.com>
Originally added in #268 to spread load across free-tier accounts when
SCRAPECREATORS_API_KEY is set to a comma-separated list. The 7-line block
was inadvertently dropped during the v3.0.6 consolidation (d14814a) even
though the changelog still advertised the feature. Re-apply the same
random.choice rotation in get_config() so user-facing behavior matches
the documented contract. Closes#287.
Co-authored-by: Eric Oberhofer <eric@oberhofer.io>
_cleanup_children() called os.killpg unconditionally — Windows doesn't
have killpg as an attribute on os, so the call raised AttributeError
(not caught by the existing OSError-family handler) and aborted cleanup.
Guard with hasattr(os, "killpg") and fall back to os.kill(pid, SIGTERM)
on platforms without process-group APIs. Closes#226. Refs #110.
Co-authored-by: gujishh <baiaoshh@163.com>
str.lstrip("r/") treats its argument as a character set, stripping
leading r and / repeatedly. Subreddits starting with 'r' (e.g. r/robotics,
r/ruby) were silently mangled to 'obotics' / 'uby'. Replace with
str.removeprefix("r/") at all four call sites. Python 3.9+ pattern is
safe here — project requires 3.12. Closes#288.
Co-authored-by: Alex Key <alexanderkey0508@gmail.com>
REPO_DIR now derives from the script's location (with env-var override)
and the Claude binary is looked up via PATH (with CLAUDE env-var override)
instead of hardcoded to /Users/mvanhorn/.local/bin/claude. Works on any
checkout. Closes#297.
Co-authored-by: Dave Morin <dave@morin.com>
Rebased onto current main where:
- instagram.py uses unified http.get (not _requests fallback); tests now
mock http.get and assert params/timeout kwargs.
- quality_nudge tests use lib.* import path with sys.path setup.
- README/CONFIGURATION.md memory-dir lines say "defaults to" so they pass
test_no_stray_hardcoded_memory_dir_paths.
The version_consistency test (test_no_stray_hardcoded_memory_dir_paths)
flagged 4 lines where `~/Documents/Last30Days/` appeared without the
canonical "defaults to" phrasing or the ${LAST30DAYS_MEMORY_DIR:-...}
literal form. Tightened the wording in the CONFIGURATION.md table +
footer paragraph, and the README "Where research files are saved"
section, so each path mention is anchored at the env-var override
contract rather than as a bare hardcoded default.
Two findings from Greptile review on PR #302:
1. tests/test_cli_v3.py:302 - The test asserted run_mock.call_args_list[0]
was the main runner's invocation, but fanout.run_competitor_fanout
submits main + competitors to a ThreadPoolExecutor and iterates with
as_completed. With zero-latency mocks, thread scheduling determines
which pipeline.run call lands first, so the competitor's call could
take index [0] and flake CI. Replace [0] indexing with a predicate
match on the canonicalized github_repos kwargs.
2. skills/last30days/scripts/last30days.py:662 - When auto_resolve returns
github_repos, it has already run canonicalize_github_repos(cap=5) and
ranked by relevance. The downstream block then re-canonicalized with
cap=None, which can re-sort by topic-slug match and clobber the
auto_resolve relevance order. Guard the second canonicalization with
a repos_from_auto_resolve flag so it only fires for user-supplied
--github-repo input.
The 6-min architecture walkthrough video is the contributor's own
work — not affiliated with the project. Removing the README pointer
to avoid implying endorsement. CONFIGURATION.md prose stands.
Both files lived at the repo root as pre-plugin-layout artifacts. On
current main neither is referenced from README, SKILL.md, AGENTS.md,
CHANGELOG, or docs/ — no inbound links to break by removing. Git history
preserves the content for anyone who needs to dig it up.
Closes#352, #353. The PRs by @dinakars777 correctly flagged the drift;
deletion is the cleaner resolution than annotating them as historical.
macOS ships /bin/bash 3.2 and the script uses #!/bin/bash with
set -euo pipefail, so declare -g would abort the SessionStart hook
with "invalid option" on every Mac. printf -v writes via assignment
semantics (global from inside a function on 3.2+) — same scope
outcome, broader compatibility.
Without this config, Greptile's documented default is `triggerOnUpdates: false`
(only the initial PR open triggers a review). Empirically Greptile has been
re-reviewing on force-push to this repo anyway, but documenting the intent
makes the behavior reliable across plan changes and any future config-source
shifts on Greptile's side.
`statusCheck: true` registers Greptile as a GitHub status check (not just a
PR comment). That gives maintainer-tooling a machine-readable heartbeat -
poll `GET /repos/.../commits/SHA/check-runs` and filter by app name to see
whether Greptile is `queued` / `in_progress` / `completed`. Without it the
only signal is "did a new Greptile comment appear" which is silently
ambiguous when Greptile re-reviews and finds nothing new.
If `statusCheck` is OSS-plan-restricted Greptile silently ignores the key,
which is fine - the rolling-summary comment with `Confidence Score: N/5`
remains the fallback signal.
Refs greptileai/skills `greploop` skill for the terminal-state pattern this
config enables.
PR #366 routes Reddit URLs found in web-search results through the public
Reddit JSON API to recover thread body + top comments (the Claude Code
WebFetch tool blocks reddit.com directly). That bypass is sound and the
fixed problem is real - but the always-on shape ignores user intent on
source gating.
A user who sets EXCLUDE_SOURCES=reddit to suppress Reddit results would
still get Reddit content smuggled back in via web-search URLs that
happen to point at reddit.com threads. This contradicts the suppression
contract that EXCLUDE_SOURCES is supposed to provide (see
lib/pipeline.available_sources where the same env var gates the
top-level Reddit source).
Add a _reddit_excluded(config) check in web_search() that mirrors the
parsing pattern from lib/pipeline (comma-separated, case-insensitive,
whitespace-tolerant). When reddit is in EXCLUDE_SOURCES, skip the
enrichment pass entirely - the web results themselves still flow
through, but they're not augmented with Reddit body/comments.
Four new tests in test_grounding_v3.py cover:
- EXCLUDE_SOURCES=reddit skips enrichment
- case-insensitive parsing matches REDDIT/Reddit/whitespace-padded/csv
- Other sources in EXCLUDE_SOURCES don't trigger the gate
- Enrichment runs normally when reddit isn't excluded
19/19 grounding tests pass.
Closes#374 (adapted, not 1:1 merged).
@hnshah opened PR #374 proposing a docs/adr/ directory for architecture
decision records. The intent is right -- the "why is search-quality eval
manual?" reasoning drifts out of memory if it isn't written down -- but
the docs/adr/ convention doesn't fit alongside the existing
docs/solutions/ structure (compound-engineering ce-compound pattern with
frontmatter metadata, additive entries, no membership-contract test).
This commit adopts hnshah's ADR 002 content (search-quality eval is
manual by default) as a docs/solutions/architecture/ entry with the
canonical compound-style frontmatter (module, problem_type, applies_when,
related_components, tags). Drops the docs/adr/ directory pattern, the
README index, and the test_adr_docs.py contract test.
ADR 001 (multi-surface packaging) is intentionally not adopted here: it
referenced sync.sh as the deploy mechanism, but sync.sh was removed in
PR #405 in favor of `npx skills add . -g -y`. The multi-surface
packaging story is still real but has moved beyond what the original
ADR captured; a fresh "how we ship to multiple harnesses" entry would
make sense as a separate doc.
Co-authored-by: hnshah <hnshah@users.noreply.github.com>
Addresses two concerns surfaced during PR #376 review:
1. **SSH option-injection on the host value.** The original PR uses
shlex.quote() on the remote command and added a `--` option terminator
in front of the host, but neither one stops a hostile env var like
`LAST30DAYS_YT_SSH_HOST=-oProxyCommand=...` from being read in the
first place. Tighten `_ytdlp_ssh_host()` to validate the host against
`^[a-zA-Z0-9._-]+$` (plain hostname/SSH-config-alias shape: letters,
digits, dot, underscore, hyphen). Any value that doesn't match logs a
warning to stderr and returns None, so the wrap function falls back to
local execution. The `--` terminator stays as defense-in-depth for the
case where a valid host happens to start with `-`, but the regex closes
the door on the env var reaching ssh at all.
2. **Env var naming consistency.** Existing skill-internal config knobs
spell out their domain: `LAST30DAYS_X_BACKEND`, `LAST30DAYS_X_MODEL`,
`LAST30DAYS_PLANNER_MODEL`, `LAST30DAYS_RERANK_MODEL`, etc. The module
is `youtube_yt.py`, the source key is `youtube`, the function family
is `is_youtube_*()` — `YT` was the odd abbreviation out. Rename to
`LAST30DAYS_YOUTUBE_SSH_HOST` so the variable matches the user mental
model ("route YouTube fetches via residential IP") and the codebase's
spelled-out convention.
Adds three new tests:
- test_host_alias_with_dash_prefix_is_rejected (validator rejects `-o...`)
- test_host_alias_with_shell_metacharacters_is_rejected (rejects spaces, ;, $, `, &)
- test_host_alias_validator_accepts_realistic_aliases (allows FQDNs, IPs, bare aliases)
The existing test_wrap_cmd_uses_option_terminator is rewritten to use a
valid host value (since an invalid one is now filtered upstream) and
continues to assert the `--` terminator placement as defense-in-depth.
44/44 youtube_yt tests pass (40 prior + 4 net new validator tests).
Greptile flagged that _cli_query's --since parsing uses datetime.now()
(local time) while first_seen is stored via SQLite's datetime('now') (UTC).
The same bug exists in three other call sites that compare against either
first_seen or run_date (both UTC):
- get_daily_cost: "today" defaults to local date, returns wrong day's cost
near UTC midnight
- get_stats: "7 days ago" cutoff for runs_7d / successful_7d
- get_trending: "N days ago" cutoff for finding activity ranking
- _cli_query: "N days ago" cutoff for --since flag (Greptile's flag)
All four now use datetime.now(timezone.utc). Same root cause and same fix
as the test_get_new_findings_filters_by_date repair in the previous commit.
CI was running only test_plugin_contract.py and test_version_consistency.py
(2 of 84 test files), masking 13 rotted tests across 4 clusters. The suite is
fully offline-safe (1402 tests in ~7s without network), so the narrow scope
wasn't gating integration flakiness; it was just stale. validate.yml now runs
`uv run pytest` against the full suite.
Engine fix: store.findings_from_report is rerank-first. ranked_candidates is
the primary persistence path; hackernews/polymarket are unconditionally
supplemented from items_by_source because they rank poorly but matter for
watchlists. When ranked_candidates was empty (rerank failed or skipped),
reddit, x, and every other source were silently dropped. The supplement loop
now falls back to all sources only when ranked_candidates is empty; the normal
path is unchanged.
Test repairs:
- test_store.py (6) + test_watchlist_commands.py (2): cascade from the engine fix
- test_get_new_findings_filters_by_date (latent): local-time vs SQLite UTC
flake — switched to datetime.now(timezone.utc)
- TestPollDeviceAuth (3): mock_time.time side_effect lists too short after
impl added a last_reminder call — padded timeout test, pinned others to
return_value=0 (loops terminate via urlopen, not the clock)
- test_bare_run_emits_web_promo: engine reads ~/.config/last30days/.env, so
a contributor's saved EXA/PARALLEL key made grounding "available" and
suppressed the web promo. Also missing X made the "x" promo preempt "web".
Set LAST30DAYS_CONFIG_DIR="", subprocess cwd=tmpdir, XAI_API_KEY stub.
PR #382 introduced an `effective_retries` widening on the first gaierror,
but the widening leaked: every non-DNS error path (HTTPError, non-DNS
URLError, OSError) was gated on `effective_retries - 1` and so inherited
the expanded bound. A caller passing `retries=2` who hit DNS-then-non-DNS
got 3 attempts instead of 2 — contrary to the PR description and the
fail-fast intent of small retry budgets.
Fix:
- Gate every non-DNS sleep/retry decision on the caller's original
`retries`, not the widened `effective_retries`.
- Add an explicit `break` in each non-DNS branch when the original
budget is exhausted, so the (possibly widened) outer loop bound
can't pull us into an extra attempt.
Adds two regression tests covering the DNS-then-non-DNS-URLError and
DNS-then-OSError sequences flagged in Greptile review on PR #382.
Two related drifts surfaced while reviewing PR #399 (EXCLUDE_SOURCES) —
docs claimed several SC-backed sources required INCLUDE_SOURCES opt-in
that the code didn't actually enforce, and threads was inconsistently
gated relative to its same-key siblings.
This commit picks the "code as source of truth + EXCLUDE_SOURCES as
suppression knob" model and aligns docs to match. It also promotes
threads to the same auto-on tier as tiktok and instagram, since all
three share the SC key and per-call cost shape — there was no real
product reason for threads being opt-in while the other two weren't.
The resulting source-gating model is three-tier and intentional:
• **Auto-on if backing infra present** (suppress via EXCLUDE_SOURCES):
reddit, HN, polymarket, X, youtube, github, bluesky, truthsocial,
grounding, **tiktok, instagram, threads**
• **INCLUDE_SOURCES persistent opt-in** (cost/billing reasons):
perplexity (different paid API — OpenRouter),
tiktok_comments / youtube_comments (N× extra SC calls per video)
• **--search per-query opt-in** (relevance reasons):
pinterest (visual pins, narrow utility),
xiaohongshu (Chinese-market specific)
Changes:
- env.py: `is_threads_available()` drops the INCLUDE_SOURCES check,
now mirrors tiktok/instagram (SC key → True). Docstring updated.
- tests/test_env_v3.py: new `ThreadsAvailabilityTests` class locks in
the new contract and includes a regression guard ("INCLUDE_SOURCES
should not be needed").
- SKILL.md: lines 333-338 rewritten so the model's "Build
ACTIVE_SOURCES_LIST" checklist reflects what the engine actually
runs. Drops false INCLUDE_SOURCES requirement for
tiktok/instagram/threads; corrects pinterest to mention --search;
adds missing INCLUDE_SOURCES=perplexity requirement.
- README: same alignment for the user-facing "Everything else in v3"
section.
Note on EXCLUDE_SOURCES references in the new docs: the suppression
flag is wired up in PR #399. SKILL.md and README mention EXCLUDE_SOURCES
as the opt-out path; that prose is forward-looking until #399 lands.
The behavior changes in this PR (threads auto-on) are self-contained
and don't require #399 to function — but for users who want to suppress
the newly-auto-on threads source, #399 needs to land first.
Greptile flagged that `entity_reports and args.emit == "html"` appeared in
two places — once when computing the footer display path, again when calling
save_output. The else-branches differ between the two callsites (the display
needs `report.topic` as fallback; the save call needs `None` so save_output
falls back to the report's own topic), so collapsing into one shared
expression would be wrong, but hoisting just the condition into a single
`is_comparison_html` bool eliminates the risk of drift while keeping the
two callsites' fallback semantics distinct.
The original PR added EXCLUDE_SOURCES filtering to pipeline.available_sources()
and to the check-config.sh banner, but env.py::get_config() builds its config
dict from a hardcoded keys list that didn't include EXCLUDE_SOURCES. The
result: setting EXCLUDE_SOURCES in the environment silently no-op'd through
the Python pipeline. Only the bash hook (which reads shell env directly)
worked. The PR's unit tests didn't catch this because they construct config
dicts directly, bypassing get_config().
Changes:
- Add ('EXCLUDE_SOURCES', '') to env.py's keys list so the env var actually
propagates into config.
- Add an end-to-end regression test that goes through get_config() rather
than constructing config dicts directly.
- Document EXCLUDE_SOURCES in SKILL.md's source-list checklist so the model
invoking the skill knows to subtract excluded sources before displaying
the active-sources line. (Per AGENTS.md: engine flags without SKILL.md
prose are incomplete — the agent invoking the skill won't know the flag
exists.)
Addresses Greptile review on PR #407:
- P1: setup-keychain.sh ALL_KEYS was missing GOOGLE_GENAI_API_KEY and
XIAOHONGSHU_API_BASE relative to _load_keychain's inline list, so users
manually storing those keys would not see them in --list and the
interactive prompt would never offer to set them.
Hoist the canonical key list into lib/env.py::KEYCHAIN_KEYS, have
get_config() pass it through, and add a parity test that parses
ALL_KEYS out of setup-keychain.sh and asserts equality. Drift is now
caught at CI time instead of after a user reports a missing key.
- P2: os.environ.get("USER", "") silently returned "" under sudo, in
Docker without --env USER, or in CI runners that strip USER. The
resulting `security find-generic-password -a ""` call would never
match items stored by setup-keychain.sh, so all lookups silently
returned nothing. Fall back to pwd.getpwuid(os.getuid()).pw_name when
USER is absent.
The P2 process-listing comment ("secret visible briefly via ps because
security has no stdin path for -w") has no clean fix — the README
already documents the manual `security add-generic-password` invocation
as an alternative for users with strict secret hygiene.